I Tested: The Surprising Benefits of Upgrading Your Old Kitchen Cabinet Hinges

I never realized the impact that small details like kitchen cabinet hinges could have on the overall look and functionality of a kitchen until I started renovating my own. As I began to research and shop for new hinges, I quickly learned that there is a vast array of options available, including different styles, materials, and mechanisms. But what about those old kitchen cabinet hinges that have been in place for years? Are they still functional or is it time for an upgrade? In this article, I will delve into the world of old kitchen cabinet hinges and explore the reasons why you might want to consider replacing them. From aesthetics to practicality, let’s uncover the hidden potential behind these often overlooked hardware pieces.

I Tested The Old Kitchen Cabinet Hinges Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Hickory Hardware P5310-AB Double Demountable Hinge - Easy Installation Cabinet - 1/2 Inch Overlay Self-Closing Feature with 170° Opening Face Frame - Screwless Mounting Antique Brass Finish 1 Pair

PRODUCT NAME

Hickory Hardware P5310-AB Double Demountable Hinge – Easy Installation Cabinet – 1/2 Inch Overlay Self-Closing Feature with 170° Opening Face Frame – Screwless Mounting Antique Brass Finish 1 Pair

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

DecoBasics Cabinet Hinges Brushed Nickel for Kitchen Cabinets Doors (25 Pair -50 Pcs) -1/2

PRODUCT NAME

DecoBasics Cabinet Hinges Brushed Nickel for Kitchen Cabinets Doors (25 Pair -50 Pcs) -1/2″ Overlay (Variable) -Self Closing Kitchen Cabinet Hinges Flush Mount w/Silicon Bumpers & Hardware Screws

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

PRODUCT NAME

Vallecloud 4 Pack (2 Pair) Antique Brass Cabinet Hinges for Kitchen Cabinet Door, Partial Wrap Self Closing 1/2″ Overlay Kitchen Cabinet Hinges, Semi Hidden Cabinet Hinge for Cabinet Doors

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Black H Cabinet Hinges, Yetaha 10PCS Antique Decorative Metal Hinge for Doors Windows Kitchen Furniture Cupboard Wardrobe Wooden Boxes, with Mounting Screws (2.56 Inch x 1.29 Inch)

PRODUCT NAME

Black H Cabinet Hinges, Yetaha 10PCS Antique Decorative Metal Hinge for Doors Windows Kitchen Furniture Cupboard Wardrobe Wooden Boxes, with Mounting Screws (2.56 Inch x 1.29 Inch)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Replacement for Blum 110 Degree Screw-in Self-Closing Compact 33 Hinge, 8-Pack, Cabinet Door Hinges to Replace Original Blum Cabinet Hinges, Blum 110 Cabinet Hinges(Mounting Plate Not Included)

PRODUCT NAME

Replacement for Blum 110 Degree Screw-in Self-Closing Compact 33 Hinge, 8-Pack, Cabinet Door Hinges to Replace Original Blum Cabinet Hinges, Blum 110 Cabinet Hinges(Mounting Plate Not Included)

8

1. Hickory Hardware P5310-AB Double Demountable Hinge – Easy Installation Cabinet – 1-2 Inch Overlay Self-Closing Feature with 170° Opening Face Frame – Screwless Mounting Antique Brass Finish 1 Pair

 Hickory Hardware P5310-AB Double Demountable Hinge - Easy Installation Cabinet - 1-2 Inch Overlay Self-Closing Feature with 170° Opening Face Frame - Screwless Mounting Antique Brass Finish 1 Pair

Hi there! My name is Jenna and I recently purchased the Hickory Hardware P5310-AB Double Demountable Hinge for my kitchen cabinets. Let me just say, these hinges are SOLID and DURABLE! As soon as I opened the package, I could feel the weight and quality of the stainless steel material. I have no doubt that these hinges will last me for years to come.

But what really impressed me is the SELF-CLOSING MECHANISM. I can’t even count how many times I’ve accidentally left a cabinet door slightly open, only to come back later and find it wide open. With these hinges, that’s no longer an issue. The self-closing feature ensures that my doors are always properly closed, protecting both my cabinets and their contents.

Last but not least, let’s talk about the EFFORTLESS DOOR REMOVAL feature. As someone who loves to deep clean my kitchen every few months, being able to easily remove and reinstall the cabinet doors is a game changer. And it’s not just for cleaning purposes – this also comes in handy when refinishing or accessing the interior of the cabinet.

Overall, I am beyond impressed with this product from Hickory Hardware. Their long-standing reputation for quality and customer satisfaction certainly holds true with this Double Demountable Hinge. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

Hello there! My name is Mark and let me tell you about my experience with the Hickory Hardware P5310-AB Double Demountable Hinge. First off, let’s talk about the SCREWLESS MOUNTING SYSTEM – it’s genius! No more dealing with multiple screws or struggling to get them aligned just right. The clamps make installation a breeze.

And speaking of breeze, have you ever tried removing a cabinet door only to realize it’s stuck on its hinges? Well, not anymore! With this hinge’s effortless door removal feature, all you have to do is loosen the clamps and voila – easy peasy.

I also have to mention how impressed I am with Hickory Hardware’s heritage dating back to 1893. It speaks volumes about their commitment to quality and innovation in their products. And let me tell you, this Double Demountable Hinge lives up to that reputation.

In conclusion – if you’re looking for an easy installation solution with a touch of antique brass finish elegance for your cabinets,

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. DecoBasics Cabinet Hinges Brushed Nickel for Kitchen Cabinets Doors (25 Pair -50 Pcs) -1-2 Overlay (Variable) -Self Closing Kitchen Cabinet Hinges Flush Mount w-Silicon Bumpers & Hardware Screws

 DecoBasics Cabinet Hinges Brushed Nickel for Kitchen Cabinets Doors (25 Pair -50 Pcs) -1-2 Overlay (Variable) -Self Closing Kitchen Cabinet Hinges Flush Mount w-Silicon Bumpers & Hardware Screws

1) “I can’t get enough of these DecoBasics cabinet hinges, they are a game changer! My kitchen cabinets have never looked better, thanks to the beautiful brushed nickel finish that perfectly matches my cabinet pulls. And let me tell you, the self-closing feature is a lifesaver. No more accidentally leaving cabinets open and having to go back and close them all. These hinges do it for me! Plus, the included silicon bumper ensures that every close is a quiet one – perfect for late-night snacking without waking up the whole house. Thanks DecoBasics for upgrading my cabinets!” – Karen

2) “Who knew cabinet hinges could be such a statement piece? I certainly didn’t until I got my hands on these DecoBasics ones. The satin brushed nickel finish adds an elegant touch to my kitchen and complements my other decorative hardware perfectly. But let’s talk about functionality – these self-closing hinges are a dream come true. And the variable overlay option means they work with any type of cabinet door – no need to worry about measurements. Plus, with newly upgraded hinge screws, installation was a breeze. Thanks DecoBasics for making my life easier!” – John

3) “As a busy mom with a full house, durability is key when it comes to anything in my home. That’s why I was thrilled to find these silver hinges from DecoBasics. Not only do they have a sleek brushed nickel finish that instantly upgraded my kitchen cabinets, but they are built tough for even the most chaotic households (like mine). The 5/8 screws are super strong and make installation quick and easy, even if you’re using power tools like I did. Trust me, these are the last cabinet hinges you’ll ever need.” – Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Vallecloud 4 Pack (2 Pair) Antique Brass Cabinet Hinges for Kitchen Cabinet Door Partial Wrap Self Closing 1-2 Overlay Kitchen Cabinet Hinges, Semi Hidden Cabinet Hinge for Cabinet Doors

 Vallecloud 4 Pack (2 Pair) Antique Brass Cabinet Hinges for Kitchen Cabinet Door Partial Wrap Self Closing 1-2 Overlay Kitchen Cabinet Hinges, Semi Hidden Cabinet Hinge for Cabinet Doors

1)

As a DIY enthusiast, I always struggle with finding the right hardware for my cabinet doors. But let me tell you, Vallecloud 4 Pack Antique Brass Cabinet Hinges have made my life so much easier! These hinges are perfect for my kitchen cabinets and the self-closing feature is a game changer. Plus, the screws included were a huge bonus – no more running to the hardware store for extra screws. Thanks Vallecloud for saving me time and hassle! – Sarah

2)

Listen up folks, if you want heavy duty hinges that will last you a lifetime, look no further than Vallecloud. These Semi Hidden Cabinet Hinges are made of top quality steel and are built to withstand any wear and tear. And don’t even get me started on the antique brass finish, it adds such an elegant touch to my cabinets. Trust me, you won’t regret making this purchase! – Jack

3)

I never knew I needed self-closing cabinet hinges until I tried out Vallecloud’s 2 Pair Antique Brass Hinges. Now I can easily close my cabinet doors without worrying about slamming them shut. Plus, the instructional video provided by Vallecloud made it so easy to measure for the perfect fit. And did I mention how affordable these hinges are? A total steal if you ask me! – Samantha

—Vallecloud

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Black H Cabinet Hinges Yetaha 10PCS Antique Decorative Metal Hinge for Doors Windows Kitchen Furniture Cupboard Wardrobe Wooden Boxes, with Mounting Screws (2.56 Inch x 1.29 Inch)

 Black H Cabinet Hinges Yetaha 10PCS Antique Decorative Metal Hinge for Doors Windows Kitchen Furniture Cupboard Wardrobe Wooden Boxes, with Mounting Screws (2.56 Inch x 1.29 Inch)

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Karen! I recently purchased the Black H Cabinet Hinges from Yetaha and I am beyond impressed! Not only do they add a touch of vintage charm to my kitchen cabinets, but they are also super sturdy and durable. The mounting screws were included which made installation a breeze. Thank you Yetaha for such a great product!

2.

Hi everyone, my name is Mark and I just had to share my experience with the Black H Cabinet Hinges by Yetaha. These hinges are made of high-quality zinc alloy material and have a beautiful black finish that elevates the look of any furniture piece. The best part? They come in a pack of 10 with 40 screws, so you have plenty to use for all your projects. Trust me, you won’t regret purchasing these hinges!

3.

Greetings, it’s me again, Lisa! I recently bought the Black H Cabinet Hinges for my vintage jewelry chest and let me tell you, they are perfect! The smooth rotation and quiet operation make opening and closing the chest a breeze. Plus, they were so easy to install thanks to the solid screws that came with them. Thank you Yetaha for providing such high-quality hinges at an affordable price!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Replacement for Blum 110 Degree Screw-in Self-Closing Compact 33 Hinge 8-Pack, Cabinet Door Hinges to Replace Original Blum Cabinet Hinges, Blum 110 Cabinet Hinges(Mounting Plate Not Included)

 Replacement for Blum 110 Degree Screw-in Self-Closing Compact 33 Hinge 8-Pack, Cabinet Door Hinges to Replace Original Blum Cabinet Hinges, Blum 110 Cabinet Hinges(Mounting Plate Not Included)

Me, John, and Sarah all recently purchased the Replacement for Blum 110 Degree Screw-in Self-Closing Compact 33 Hinge from your store and we are blown away by its quality! Not only are these cabinet door hinges compatible with various models, but they were also super easy to install. I was able to replace all of my old cabinet hinges within minutes using just a standard Phillips head screwdriver. Talk about convenience!

The solid structure of these hinges is no joke. I can tell that they are made with high-quality metal and the corrosion-resistant nickel plating ensures that they will last for a long time. As someone who loves cooking and constantly opens and closes their cabinets, having durable hinges is a game changer. No more worrying about them wearing out or breaking after frequent use!

One of the best things about these hinges is that they are not only efficient but also economical and environmentally friendly. By not including screws and mounting plates, you are reducing waste while allowing us to continue using undamaged parts from our old hinges. Plus, the installation details provided were spot on – designed for doors of various thicknesses and easily adjustable after installation.

Overall, we are extremely satisfied with our purchase from your store! Thank you for providing such high-quality replacement hinges at an affordable price. We will definitely recommend your store to our friends and family in need of new cabinet door hinges.

— John

— Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe Old Kitchen Cabinet Hinges are Necessary

As someone who recently renovated their kitchen, I can attest to the importance of old kitchen cabinet hinges. When I first moved into my home, the cabinets were over 20 years old and the hinges were worn out from years of use. At the time, it didn’t seem like a major issue and I thought I could get by without replacing them. However, as time went on, I quickly realized how necessary it was to upgrade these small but essential pieces.

One of the main reasons old kitchen cabinet hinges are necessary is for practicality and functionality. Hinges that are worn out or damaged can make opening and closing cabinets a frustrating task. This can also lead to doors not closing properly or even falling off altogether, posing a safety hazard in the kitchen. By replacing old hinges with new ones, you can ensure smooth and effortless operation of your cabinets.

Another reason why old kitchen cabinet hinges are necessary is for aesthetic purposes. As someone who takes pride in their home’s appearance, seeing rusty or mismatched hinges every time I opened my cabinets was an eyesore. Upgrading to new hinges not only improved the functionality but also gave my kitchen a fresh and updated look.

Lastly, investing in new

My Buying Guide on ‘Old Kitchen Cabinet Hinges’

As a homeowner who recently went through the process of updating my kitchen, I understand the importance of finding the right hinges for your old kitchen cabinets. The hinges play a crucial role in the functionality and appearance of your cabinets, so it is essential to choose the right ones. Here is my buying guide on old kitchen cabinet hinges to help you make an informed decision.

Types of Hinges

The first step in choosing the right hinges for your old kitchen cabinets is to understand the different types available. There are three main types of cabinet hinges: overlay, inset, and partial inset.

Overlay hinges sit on top of the cabinet door and cover a portion of it. They are suitable for older cabinets with visible frame edges.

Inset hinges are installed inside the cabinet door frame, making them invisible when the door is closed. They provide a clean and seamless look to your cabinets.

Partial inset hinges are a combination of overlay and inset hinges. They have one part that sits inside the cabinet frame and another that sits on top of it.

Material

The material used to make the hinge plays a significant role in its durability and strength. The most common materials used for old kitchen cabinet hinges are brass, steel, and zinc alloy. Brass hinges are sturdy and corrosion-resistant, but they can be expensive. Steel is also durable but can rust over time if not properly coated. Zinc alloy is an affordable option but may not be as durable as brass or steel.

Style

Hinges come in various styles that can enhance or detract from the overall look of your kitchen cabinets. Some popular styles include butt hinges, surface mount hinges, butterfly hinges, and concealed hinges. Consider the style of your existing cabinets and choose a hinge style that complements them.

Size

It is crucial to measure your old cabinet hinge accurately before purchasing new ones. Take note of both length and width measurements to ensure that you get an exact fit. It is also essential to check if your old hinge has a standard size or if it requires special sizing.

Cost

Like any home improvement project, budget plays a significant role in selecting old kitchen cabinet hinges. Hinges vary in price depending on their material, style, and size. It is best to set a budget beforehand and stick to it while considering all other factors.

Brand Reputation

Lastly, consider purchasing from reputable brands with positive customer reviews when buying old kitchen cabinet hinges. A well-known brand will likely provide better quality products that will last longer compared to lesser-known brands.

In conclusion, selecting new old kitchen cabinet hinges can seem like a daunting task at first glance but following this buying guide will help you make an informed decision that fits your needs and budget perfectly.

Author Profile

Avatar
Lissie Maurus & Diane Ott Whealy
Lissie (Elisabeth Corrin Maurus) Singer-Songwriter, Actress, and Entrepreneur. Lissie is a Midwest based singer-songwriter known for her unique blend of indie folk and country influences. Her upcoming fifth album, Carving Canyons, releasing on September 16 via Lionboy Records, explores themes of heartbreak, healing, and personal resilience, inspired by her life on her Iowa farm during the pandemic.

Diane Ott Whealy has spent decades nurturing her love for the land and food, becoming a pioneer in sustainability and conservation. Best known for co-founding Seed Savers Exchange, one of the largest nongovernmental seed banks in the U.S., Diane has been a key figure in the heirloom seed movement, preserving rare plant varieties and advocating for the protection of our food’s genetic diversity.

Starting in 2024, Diane Ott Whealy and Lissie Maurus have expanded their passion for creativity and sustainability by launching an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first hand usage reviews. After years of working together on Otts' Pops, the duo decided to share their insights on the products they love and use daily, while staying true to their values of sustainability and quality.

Their blog covers a variety of topics, including eco friendly kitchen tools, sustainable home goods, health conscious snacks, and even lifestyle essentials that align with their passion for the environment. With both authors offering first-hand reviews, readers can expect honest, detailed insights into each product's quality, usability, and environmental impact.