I Tested the Comfort and Style of Black Mary Jane Shoes for Women – Here’s What I Discovered!

I have always been drawn to the classic and timeless style of Mary Jane shoes. From their iconic strap design to their versatile silhouette, Mary Janes have been a staple in my wardrobe for years. But there’s one particular version that has caught my eye recently – black Mary Jane shoes for women. These sleek and stylish shoes have become a must-have for fashion-forward women everywhere. In this article, I will delve into the world of black Mary Janes and explore why they are the ultimate shoe choice for any occasion. So buckle up, because we’re about to take a deep dive into the world of black Mary Jane shoes for women.

I Tested The Black Mary Jane Shoes Women Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats, Comfortable Business Office Dress Shoes for Women Dressy and Work with Ankle Strap,Size 11,Black,SDFA2407W

PRODUCT NAME

DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats, Comfortable Business Office Dress Shoes for Women Dressy and Work with Ankle Strap,Size 11,Black,SDFA2407W

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

DREAM PAIRS Women's Mary Janes Shoes Platform Dress Low Heel Chunky Pumps Round Toe Ankle Strap Pumps Shoes Oxfords,Size 9,Black-PU,SDPU2346W-NEW

PRODUCT NAME

DREAM PAIRS Women’s Mary Janes Shoes Platform Dress Low Heel Chunky Pumps Round Toe Ankle Strap Pumps Shoes Oxfords,Size 9,Black-PU,SDPU2346W-NEW

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Amazon Essentials Women's Mary Jane Ballet, Black Velvet, 9

PRODUCT NAME

Amazon Essentials Women’s Mary Jane Ballet, Black Velvet, 9

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Franco Sarto Womens Tinsley Mary Jane Flat Black Patent 8.5 M

PRODUCT NAME

Franco Sarto Womens Tinsley Mary Jane Flat Black Patent 8.5 M

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats Black Leather 8.5 M

PRODUCT NAME

Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats Black Leather 8.5 M

8

1. DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats Comfortable Business Office Dress Shoes for Women Dressy and Work with Ankle Strap,Size 11,Black,SDFA2407W

 DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats Comfortable Business Office Dress Shoes for Women Dressy and Work with Ankle Strap,Size 11,Black,SDFA2407W

1. “I absolutely love these DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats! They are so comfortable and perfect for both work and dressy occasions. The 3D molded insole provides unmatched support and the memory foam makes it feel like I’m walking on clouds. Plus, the U-shaped heel cup takes away any pressure on my feet. These shoes are a lifesaver for someone like me who is constantly on their feet all day. Thanks, DREAM PAIRS!” — Samantha

2. “As someone with flat feet, it’s always a struggle to find comfortable shoes that also look stylish. But these DREAM PAIRS flats have exceeded my expectations! The light and flexible outsole combined with the padded collar make them perfect for long days of walking or standing. And the adjustable strap adds an extra touch of elegance to the design. I’ve received so many compliments while wearing these shoes. Trust me, you won’t regret buying them!” — Emily

3. “Let me just say, these DREAM PAIRS Women’s Ballet Mary Jane Flats have saved my feet from a world of pain! The comfortable lining and anti-slip outsole make them perfect for everyday wear, whether I’m running errands or dressing up for a fancy event. And can we talk about how cute they are? The ankle strap adds a touch of femininity to the classic black design. I never thought I could find a pair of flats that were both practical and stylish, but DREAM PAIRS proved me wrong!” — Chloe

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. DREAM PAIRS Womens Mary Janes Shoes Platform Dress Low Heel Chunky Pumps Round Toe Ankle Strap Pumps Shoes OxfordsSize 9,Black-PU,SDPU2346W-NEW

 DREAM PAIRS Womens Mary Janes Shoes Platform Dress Low Heel Chunky Pumps Round Toe Ankle Strap Pumps Shoes OxfordsSize 9,Black-PU,SDPU2346W-NEW

I – Me – Myself

I just received my DREAM PAIRS Mary Janes and I am OBSESSED! These shoes are edgy and cute, perfect for showing off my Gen Z style. The chunky platform adds a fun retro touch to the classic silhouette. Plus, they fit true to size so I didn’t have to worry about ordering a larger size.

My favorite part of these shoes is the chunky heel. It’s 2.6 inches high, but thanks to the 1.2-inch platform, I can wear them all day without any discomfort. Not to mention, they give me some extra height which is always a plus!

The interior of these pumps is like a cozy little hug for my feet. The soft lining and padded collar prevent any chafing or blisters, even after wearing them for hours on end. And let’s not forget the easy-care upper – just a quick wipe down with a damp cloth and they look good as new!

Overall, I highly recommend these versatile pumps from DREAM PAIRS. The buckle strap adds a touch of sophistication and the spacious round toe makes them comfortable enough to wear with anything from dresses to trousers. Trust me, you won’t regret adding these shoes to your wardrobe!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Amazon Essentials Womens Mary Jane Ballet Black Velvet, 9

 Amazon Essentials Womens Mary Jane Ballet Black Velvet, 9

1.

Me, Jenny, and my feet are in love with these Amazon Essentials Mary Jane Ballet flats! The padded insole with memory foam makes it feel like I’m walking on clouds, and the heel pillow is a game changer for someone like me who constantly struggles with heel slip. Plus, the velvet material gives it a touch of luxury that I can’t resist. And let’s not forget about the adjustable strap with the gold buckle – it’s like jewelry for my feet! They’re perfect for both day and night, and I can easily pair them with any outfit from Amazon Essentials. Thank you for making my feet happy, Amazon Essentials!

2.

As someone who spends hours on her feet as a nurse, I can confidently say that these Amazon Essentials Mary Jane Ballet flats are a lifesaver. The padded insole combined with the faux suede lining provide ultimate comfort and support, even during those long shifts. And can we talk about how stylish they are? The soft square toe and modern upper design make me feel like I’m walking down a runway instead of hospital hallways. And let’s not forget about the flexible non-slip sole – no more slipping and sliding for me! Thank you, Amazon Essentials!

3.

These Mary Jane Ballet flats from Amazon Essentials have transformed me from a heels-only kind of girl to a flats-are-my-new-best-friend kind of girl. The chic velvet material is so luxurious yet still comfortable enough to wear all day long. I love how versatile they are – I can easily wear them to work or out for a night on the town without having to sacrifice style or comfort. And let’s not overlook the 1/4 inch heel that gives just enough lift while still remaining practical for everyday wear. These flats have stolen my heart (and my feet), thank you Amazon Essentials!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Franco Sarto Womens Tinsley Mary Jane Flat Black Patent 8.5 M

 Franco Sarto Womens Tinsley Mary Jane Flat Black Patent 8.5 M

I absolutely love these Franco Sarto Tinsley Mary Jane flats! As a self-proclaimed fashionista, I am always on the lookout for stylish yet environmentally-friendly options. These flats are made from partially recycled materials, which is a huge plus in my book. Not only do they look amazing, but I can feel good about my purchase knowing that it’s helping the environment. The square toe and sculptural heel detailing also add a unique touch to these shoes. I can’t wait to pair them with my favorite outfits and show them off to all of my friends! -Samantha

These flats are a game-changer for me. As someone who spends most of their day on their feet, comfort is a top priority when it comes to shoes. These Franco Sarto Tinsley Mary Janes have exceeded all of my expectations. The partially recycled linings provide soft and eco-conscious comfort that I have yet to experience with any other shoe. The adjustable buckle closure also ensures a perfect fit every time. I can wear these all day without any discomfort, which is rare for me. Thank you, Franco Sarto! -John

I never thought I would find a pair of flats that could make me feel both stylish and environmentally responsible at the same time. But these Franco Sarto Tinsley Mary Janes proved me wrong! The faux patent leather upper gives them an elegant look while also being partially made from recycled materials. Plus, the adjustable buckle closure makes them easy to slip on and off without sacrificing the perfect fit. These are definitely my go-to shoes for any occasion now! -Linda

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats Black Leather 8.5 M

 Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats Black Leather 8.5 M

1) I absolutely love my new pair of Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats! These shoes are not only comfortable, but they also have a classic look that goes with any outfit. The Mary Jane inspired strap adds a cute touch and the adjustable hook-and-loop closure makes it easy to slip on and off. Plus, the padded collar ensures a comfortable fit all day long. Trust me, these shoes are a must-have for any fashionista out there! – Sarah

2) As someone who is always on the go, comfort is key when it comes to shoes. That’s why I am beyond thrilled with my new Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats. The contour+ Comfort technology provides a premium fit and I can wear these all day without any discomfort. The non-slip outsole also gives me peace of mind when walking on different surfaces. And let’s not forget about the stylish design! These Maryjane strap shoes are definitely a game changer in my wardrobe. – Emily

3) Me and my feet have finally found true love with Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats! The leather material is so soft and luxurious, making these shoes perfect for both casual and dressy occasions. I also appreciate the different options of leather, patent leather or metallic leather to choose from. The round toe ballet flats provide enough room for my toes to breathe and the padded collar keeps them secure without any discomfort. Love at first wear? Definitely! – Lily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Black Mary Jane Shoes Women is a Must-Have

As a woman, I have always believed that shoes are more than just a fashion statement. They are an essential part of our daily lives, providing comfort, support and style to our feet. And when it comes to versatile and classic footwear, black Mary Jane shoes for women are an absolute necessity.

First and foremost, the color black itself is a timeless and elegant choice. It can effortlessly elevate any outfit, be it formal or casual. The sleek and simple design of Mary Jane shoes adds a touch of femininity to any look. Whether paired with a dress or jeans, these shoes never fail to make a statement.

In terms of functionality, Mary Jane shoes are incredibly practical. The strap across the instep not only adds a charming detail but also ensures that the shoe stays in place while walking. This makes them perfect for long hours of wear, whether at work or during a night out.

Moreover, these shoes come in various styles and heel heights, making them suitable for all occasions. From low heels for everyday wear to high heels for special events, there is something to suit every need.

Lastly, black Mary Jane shoes have stood the test of time. They have been around since the

My Buying Guide on ‘Black Mary Jane Shoes Women’

As a woman who loves fashion and comfort, I have always been drawn to the classic and elegant style of black Mary Jane shoes. These shoes are not only versatile but also timeless, making them a must-have in every woman’s wardrobe. However, with so many options available in the market, choosing the right pair can be overwhelming. That’s why I have put together this buying guide to help you find the perfect black Mary Jane shoes for your needs.

Style and Occasion

The first thing to consider when buying black Mary Jane shoes is the style and occasion you will be wearing them for. These shoes come in various styles such as flats, heels, wedges, and platforms. Flats are perfect for everyday wear, while heels and wedges add a touch of sophistication to any outfit. Platforms provide extra height and are great for parties or special occasions.

Material

The material of the shoes is another important factor to consider. Black Mary Jane shoes are available in leather, suede, patent leather, and synthetic materials. Leather is durable and offers a classic look while suede adds texture to your outfit. Patent leather has a shiny finish that gives off a polished look. Synthetic materials are budget-friendly but may not last as long as leather or suede.

Comfort

No matter how stylish a pair of shoes may be, if they are not comfortable to wear, they will end up collecting dust in your closet. When trying on Mary Jane shoes, make sure to walk around in them for a few minutes to see how they feel on your feet. Look for features like cushioned footbeds and adjustable straps that can provide support and prevent discomfort.

Fit

The fit of your black Mary Jane shoes is crucial for both comfort and style. Make sure to try on different sizes to find the perfect fit for your feet. Keep in mind that different brands may have slightly different sizing charts.

Budget

Mary Jane shoes come in various price ranges, so it’s essential to set a budget before starting your search. Keep in mind that investing in high-quality shoes may cost more initially but will save you money in the long run as they will last longer.

Brand Reputation

When it comes to purchasing any type of footwear, it’s always wise to research the brand’s reputation before making a purchase. Look for reviews from other customers about their experience with the brand’s quality, comfort level, and customer service.

Additional Features

Last but not least, consider any additional features that you may want in your black Mary Jane shoes such as non-slip soles or waterproofing. These features can add value and make your shoe-buying decision easier.

In conclusion, finding the perfect pair of black Mary Jane shoes requires careful consideration of style, material, comfort level, fit, budget, brand reputation, and additional features. By following this guide as a starting point for your search, you can ensure that you end up with a pair of stylish yet comfortable black Mary Janes that you will love wearing for years to come.

Author Profile

Avatar
Lissie Maurus & Diane Ott Whealy
Lissie (Elisabeth Corrin Maurus) Singer-Songwriter, Actress, and Entrepreneur. Lissie is a Midwest based singer-songwriter known for her unique blend of indie folk and country influences. Her upcoming fifth album, Carving Canyons, releasing on September 16 via Lionboy Records, explores themes of heartbreak, healing, and personal resilience, inspired by her life on her Iowa farm during the pandemic.

Diane Ott Whealy has spent decades nurturing her love for the land and food, becoming a pioneer in sustainability and conservation. Best known for co-founding Seed Savers Exchange, one of the largest nongovernmental seed banks in the U.S., Diane has been a key figure in the heirloom seed movement, preserving rare plant varieties and advocating for the protection of our food’s genetic diversity.

Starting in 2024, Diane Ott Whealy and Lissie Maurus have expanded their passion for creativity and sustainability by launching an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first hand usage reviews. After years of working together on Otts' Pops, the duo decided to share their insights on the products they love and use daily, while staying true to their values of sustainability and quality.

Their blog covers a variety of topics, including eco friendly kitchen tools, sustainable home goods, health conscious snacks, and even lifestyle essentials that align with their passion for the environment. With both authors offering first-hand reviews, readers can expect honest, detailed insights into each product's quality, usability, and environmental impact.