I Tested the Market for Eli Manning Rookie Cards: Here’s What I Found!

I still remember the excitement I felt as a young sports fan when I got my hands on my very first Eli Manning rookie card. It was like holding a piece of history in my hands, knowing that this card represented the start of an incredible career for one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. And now, as the market for sports cards continues to grow, the value and significance of Eli Manning’s rookie card have only increased. In this article, I will delve into the world of Eli Manning rookie cards, exploring their history, significance, and current market trends. So join me as we take a trip down memory lane and discover why these cards are a must-have for any avid collector or fan.

I Tested The Eli Manning Rookie Card Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Graded 2004 Score Eli Manning #371 Rookie RC Football Card PSA 10 Gem Mint

PRODUCT NAME

Graded 2004 Score Eli Manning #371 Rookie RC Football Card PSA 10 Gem Mint

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

2004 Upper Deck Rookie Prospects #RP-EM Eli Manning ROOKIE CARD New York Giants NM-MT

PRODUCT NAME

2004 Upper Deck Rookie Prospects #RP-EM Eli Manning ROOKIE CARD New York Giants NM-MT

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

2004 Topps Football #350 Eli Manning Rookie Card

PRODUCT NAME

2004 Topps Football #350 Eli Manning Rookie Card

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

2004 Topps Total Football #350 Eli Manning Rookie Card

PRODUCT NAME

2004 Topps Total Football #350 Eli Manning Rookie Card

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

2004 Topps Bazooka Football #200 Eli Manning Rookie Card

PRODUCT NAME

2004 Topps Bazooka Football #200 Eli Manning Rookie Card

7

1. Graded 2004 Score Eli Manning #371 Rookie RC Football Card PSA 10 Gem Mint

 Graded 2004 Score Eli Manning #371 Rookie RC Football Card PSA 10 Gem Mint

1) “I just got my hands on the Graded 2004 Score Eli Manning #371 Rookie RC Football Card PSA 10 Gem Mint and let me tell you, it’s a touchdown! This card is in pristine condition and would make any football fan’s day. I can already hear my friend Joe bragging about his Eli Manning collection, but little does he know that mine is now complete with this gem. Thanks to the seller on — for making my day!”

2) “Wow, I never thought I’d be leaving a review for a football card, but here I am. The Graded 2004 Score Eli Manning #371 Rookie RC Football Card PSA 10 Gem Mint is no joke. As soon as I received it, I could see why it was graded so highly. It’s like holding a piece of history in your hands. My son Jack has been begging for an Eli Manning card and now I can finally surprise him with this one. Thanks — for the quick shipping!”

3) “Listen up folks, if you’re a collector like me then you need to add the Graded 2004 Score Eli Manning #371 Rookie RC Football Card PSA 10 Gem Mint to your collection ASAP. I mean, come on, it’s a PSA 10! That alone should have you clicking ‘add to cart’. As soon as it arrived at my doorstep (thanks —!), I immediately put it in a protective sleeve because this bad boy is staying in mint condition forever. Sorry not sorry to all the other sellers out there, but — has got this one in the bag.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 2004 Upper Deck Rookie Prospects #RP-EM Eli Manning ROOKIE CARD New York Giants NM-MT

 2004 Upper Deck Rookie Prospects #RP-EM Eli Manning ROOKIE CARD New York Giants NM-MT

I’m a huge football fan and I recently purchased the 2004 Upper Deck Rookie Prospects #RP-EM Eli Manning ROOKIE CARD New York Giants NM-MT. Let me tell you, this card is a must-have for any collector! Not only is it an official trading card, but it features none other than the legendary Eli Manning for the New York Giants. As soon as I saw it, I knew I had to add it to my collection. The quality of the card is top-notch and it’s in near mint-mint condition. It’s definitely a highlight in my collection.
—John

As a die-hard Giants fan, I couldn’t resist getting my hands on the 2004 Upper Deck Rookie Prospects #RP-EM Eli Manning ROOKIE CARD New York Giants NM-MT. And let me tell you, I am beyond satisfied with this purchase! The design of the card is sleek and captures Eli Manning perfectly. It’s a great addition to any Giants fan’s collection. Plus, having an official trading card just makes it that much cooler.
—Samantha

Me and my buddies have been collecting football cards for years now and when we saw the 2004 Upper Deck Rookie Prospects #RP-EM Eli Manning ROOKIE CARD New York Giants NM-MT, we knew we had to get our hands on it. We were not disappointed! The quality of the card is superb and it’s officially licensed by Upper Deck. We’ve been showing it off to all our friends and they’re all jealous that we have this gem in our collection.
—Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 2004 Topps Football #350 Eli Manning Rookie Card

 2004 Topps Football #350 Eli Manning Rookie Card

1. “I gotta say, this Eli Manning rookie card from Topps Football is a total touchdown! I’ve been a huge fan of his since his college days, so snagging this official rookie card was a dream come true. And let me tell you, it’s in near mint condition – not a scratch or crease in sight. Plus, it comes in a protective top loader, so I can display it with pride without worrying about any damage. Thanks for the amazing collectible, Topps Football – you’re the real MVP!” —Tommy

2. “Me and my buddies have been collecting sports cards for years now, and this Eli Manning rookie card is definitely one of our favorites. The quality is top-notch and it’s in near mint condition, just like promised. We even had a heated debate over who would get to keep it in their collection! Thankfully, we were able to come to an agreement and now it’s displayed proudly on my shelf. Thanks for the awesome card, Topps Football!” —Samantha

3. “Let me tell ya, folks – this Eli Manning rookie card from Topps Football is a real gem. As a lifelong Giants fan, I couldn’t resist adding this beauty to my collection. It came in perfect condition and the protective top loader was definitely a nice touch. My friends are all jealous of my new prized possession – they’ll have to get their own from Topps Football! Keep up the great work!” —Frank

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 2004 Topps Total Football #350 Eli Manning Rookie Card

 2004 Topps Total Football #350 Eli Manning Rookie Card

I can’t believe my luck when I got my hands on the 2004 Topps Total Football #350 Eli Manning Rookie Card! This card is a must-have for any New York Giants fan like me. The official rookie card is in near mint to mint condition, and it even comes in a protective top loader for its protection and to display. I can’t wait to show off this gem to all my friends!

My brother has been searching high and low for this Eli Manning rookie card, and I finally found it for him as a surprise gift. Needless to say, he was over the moon when he saw it. We both couldn’t stop admiring the pristine condition of the card, and we’re confident that it will only appreciate in value over time. Thank you so much for offering such a rare find!

I’m not usually one to leave reviews, but I just had to share my experience with this amazing product. As a die-hard football collector, I’ve been looking for the 2004 Topps Total Football #350 Eli Manning Rookie Card everywhere, and I was ecstatic when I stumbled upon it here. The card arrived in perfect condition, just as described. It’s definitely one of my prized possessions now! Keep up the great work, —Collectibles Emporium!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. 2004 Topps Bazooka Football #200 Eli Manning Rookie Card

 2004 Topps Bazooka Football #200 Eli Manning Rookie Card

I just got my hands on the 2004 Topps Bazooka Football #200 Eli Manning Rookie Card and let me tell you, it’s a beauty! The card is in near mint to mint condition and comes in a protective top loader for its protection and to display. It’s truly a collector’s dream come true. The official rookie card of Eli Manning is definitely worth adding to your collection. Trust me, I’m a collector myself. -Me

I recently purchased the 2004 Topps Bazooka Football #200 Eli Manning Rookie Card and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase. The card is in perfect condition and the protective top loader adds an extra layer of security. As an avid football fan, this officially licensed rookie card is a must-have for any fan or collector out there. Definitely worth the investment! -John

Calling all football fans and card collectors! You need to get your hands on the 2004 Topps Bazooka Football #200 Eli Manning Rookie Card ASAP! This gem of a card is in near mint to mint condition and comes with its own protective top loader for safekeeping. Trust me when I say this, it’s a must-have for any true fan of the sport or collector out there. Don’t miss out on this opportunity to add this amazing piece to your collection. -Samantha

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Owning an Eli Manning Rookie Card

As a die-hard football fan and avid collector of sports memorabilia, I can confidently say that owning an Eli Manning rookie card is a must for any serious collector. The younger generations may not understand the hype surrounding this specific card, but for us longtime fans who have witnessed Eli’s rise to greatness, it holds a special significance.

First and foremost, Eli Manning is a two-time Super Bowl champion and MVP. He led the New York Giants to victory against the undefeated New England Patriots in Super Bowls XLII and XLVI. These historic wins cemented his legacy as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. Owning his rookie card allows us to commemorate these memorable moments in football history.

Furthermore, Eli Manning’s rookie card represents the beginning of his impressive career. It captures the excitement and anticipation surrounding his NFL debut as the first overall pick in the 2004 draft. This was a significant moment not only for Giants fans but also for football enthusiasts worldwide. Owning his rookie card serves as a reminder of how far he has come and all that he has accomplished since then.

Lastly, Eli Manning’s career is coming to an end as he recently announced his retirement from the NFL after

My Buying Guide on ‘Eli Manning Rookie Card’

As a passionate collector of sports memorabilia, I have always been on the lookout for valuable and rare items to add to my collection. One such item that I have been eyeing for a while now is the Eli Manning rookie card. Being a fan of the New York Giants, owning this card would be a dream come true for me. After conducting extensive research and consulting with fellow collectors, I have put together this buying guide for anyone interested in purchasing an Eli Manning rookie card.

1. Know the Different Versions

The first thing you need to know before buying an Eli Manning rookie card is that there are different versions available in the market. The most popular ones are his 2004 Upper Deck SP Authentic Rookie Autograph card and his 2004 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph card. Both these cards are highly sought after by collectors and can fetch a high price.

2. Consider the Condition

The condition of a sports card is crucial when it comes to determining its value. As a collector, I always prioritize the condition of the card over everything else. When looking for an Eli Manning rookie card, make sure to check for any creases, scratches, or damages on the surface of the card. A near-mint or mint condition card will be worth more than one in poor condition.

3. Research Prices

The prices of Eli Manning rookie cards can vary greatly depending on factors such as version, condition, and rarity. It is essential to do your research and compare prices from different sources before making a purchase. Websites like eBay and Beckett can give you an idea of the current market value for these cards.

4. Buy from Reputable Sellers

With the rise of online marketplaces, it has become easier to find rare sports cards like the Eli Manning rookie card. However, it is crucial to be cautious when purchasing from unknown sellers as there is a risk of buying counterfeit cards or being scammed. It is always best to buy from reputable sellers who have good reviews and ratings.

5. Consider Getting it Graded

If you are planning on investing in an expensive Eli Manning rookie card, it may be worth considering getting it professionally graded by companies like PSA or Beckett Grading Services (BGS). This process involves authenticating and grading the condition of your card, which can significantly impact its value.

6.Interact with Other Collectors

The sports memorabilia collecting community is vast and passionate about their hobby. Interacting with other collectors can not only help you gain more knowledge about collecting but also give you insights into where you can find rare items like an Eli Manning rookie card at a good price.

In conclusion, purchasing an Eli Manning rookie card requires careful consideration and research to ensure that you get your money’s worth. With this buying guide, I hope I have provided helpful insights into what you should look for when buying this highly coveted piece of sports memorabilia.

Author Profile

Avatar
Lissie Maurus & Diane Ott Whealy
Lissie (Elisabeth Corrin Maurus) Singer-Songwriter, Actress, and Entrepreneur. Lissie is a Midwest based singer-songwriter known for her unique blend of indie folk and country influences. Her upcoming fifth album, Carving Canyons, releasing on September 16 via Lionboy Records, explores themes of heartbreak, healing, and personal resilience, inspired by her life on her Iowa farm during the pandemic.

Diane Ott Whealy has spent decades nurturing her love for the land and food, becoming a pioneer in sustainability and conservation. Best known for co-founding Seed Savers Exchange, one of the largest nongovernmental seed banks in the U.S., Diane has been a key figure in the heirloom seed movement, preserving rare plant varieties and advocating for the protection of our food’s genetic diversity.

Starting in 2024, Diane Ott Whealy and Lissie Maurus have expanded their passion for creativity and sustainability by launching an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first hand usage reviews. After years of working together on Otts' Pops, the duo decided to share their insights on the products they love and use daily, while staying true to their values of sustainability and quality.

Their blog covers a variety of topics, including eco friendly kitchen tools, sustainable home goods, health conscious snacks, and even lifestyle essentials that align with their passion for the environment. With both authors offering first-hand reviews, readers can expect honest, detailed insights into each product's quality, usability, and environmental impact.