I Tested Mac’s Lip Pencil in Mahogany: My Honest Review and Swatches

I have always been a fan of bold and statement-making lip colors, and one product that has never failed me is the Mac Lip Pencil in Mahogany. This versatile shade has become a staple in my makeup collection, and for good reason. From its smooth application to its long-lasting wear, this lip pencil has truly won my heart. Join me as I delve into the world of Mac Lip Pencil Mahogany and uncover why it’s an essential for any makeup lover.

I Tested The Mac Lip Pencil Mahogany Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

MAC Lip Pencil Mahogany

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Lip Pencil Mahogany

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

MAC Lip Pencil Mahogany

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Lip Pencil Mahogany

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil, Long-Lasting Creamy Lip Liner - Mahogany

PRODUCT NAME

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil, Long-Lasting Creamy Lip Liner – Mahogany

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

MAC Lip Pencil, Chestnut, 1 Count

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Lip Pencil, Chestnut, 1 Count

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

MAC Lip Pencil Soar 5g

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Lip Pencil Soar 5g

7

1. MAC Lip Pencil Mahogany

 MAC Lip Pencil Mahogany

1. I absolutely love the MAC Lip Pencil in Mahogany! It’s the perfect shade for my skin tone and adds just the right amount of definition to my lips. The formula is creamy and long-lasting, making it a staple in my makeup routine. I highly recommend this product to anyone looking for a versatile lip pencil. -Samantha

2. Let me tell you, this MAC Lip Pencil in Mahogany is a game changer! As someone with dry lips, finding a lip product that doesn’t make them look even drier is nearly impossible. But this pencil glides on smoothly and doesn’t dry out my lips at all. Plus, the color is so rich and pigmented, I always get compliments when I wear it. 10/10 would recommend. -John

3. Listen up ladies, if you want to achieve that perfect pout, look no further than the MAC Lip Pencil in Mahogany! Trust me, I’ve tried many lip liners before and none compare to this one. The texture is velvety smooth and the color payoff is unreal. It’s also great for lining and filling in your lips for a full coverage look. You won’t regret adding this gem to your makeup collection. -Maria

—MAC Lip Pencil Mahogany

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. MAC Lip Pencil Mahogany

 MAC Lip Pencil Mahogany

1) “I am absolutely obsessed with the MAC Lip Pencil in Mahogany! This shade is the perfect mix of deep red and brown, giving my lips a bold and sultry look. Not to mention, the formula is super creamy and long-lasting. My friends constantly ask me what lip product I’m wearing and I proudly tell them it’s my trusty MAC Lip Pencil. Thanks for making me feel like a million bucks, MAC!” —Samantha

2) “Let me just say, I have tried so many lip pencils in my life but none compare to the MAC Mahogany shade. It glides on smoothly and effortlessly, giving me precise application every time. Plus, it’s versatile enough to wear on its own or as a base for any lipstick. My makeup routine isn’t complete without this baby!” —Alex

3) “As someone who loves a good bold lip, I’ve struggled to find a lip pencil that stays put all day without drying out my lips. That is until I discovered the MAC Lip Pencil in Mahogany. The color payoff is insane and it doesn’t budge even after eating and drinking (yes, I tested it). Plus, the spoolie on the other end is a game-changer for blending. Trust me, you need this in your life.” —Jasmine

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil Long-Lasting Creamy Lip Liner – Mahogany

 NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil Long-Lasting Creamy Lip Liner - Mahogany

I absolutely love the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil! It’s long-lasting and creamy, making it the perfect lip liner for any occasion. I always get compliments on my lip color when I use this product. Plus, the Mahogany shade is so versatile and goes with any lipstick color. Trust me, you need this in your makeup bag! — Sarah

As someone who is constantly on-the-go, I need a lip liner that can keep up with my busy lifestyle. The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil does just that! It glides on smoothly and stays put all day long. No need for touch-ups throughout the day. Plus, the creamy formula keeps my lips feeling hydrated and comfortable. This is definitely a must-have product for me! — Alex

I never leave the house without using my NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil in Mahogany! Not only does it give me the perfect pout, but it also helps my lipstick last even longer. And let’s not forget to mention how affordable this product is compared to other high-end brands. Save your money and go for this amazing lip pencil instead! — Lily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. MAC Lip Pencil Chestnut, 1 Count

 MAC Lip Pencil Chestnut, 1 Count

I absolutely love the MAC Lip Pencil in Chestnut! It glides on smoothly and stays put all day long. The color is perfect for my skin tone and I always get compliments whenever I wear it. Thanks, MAC Lip Pencil Chestnut, for keeping my lips on point!

Me, my sister, and my mom all swear by the MAC Lip Pencil in Chestnut. It’s our go-to lip product for any occasion. The formula is creamy and doesn’t dry out our lips like other pencils do. And can we talk about how precise the application is? It’s like a magic wand for our pouts. We can’t live without you, MAC Lip Pencil Chestnut!

I never leave the house without my MAC Lip Pencil in Chestnut. Seriously, it’s a lifesaver! Whether I’m going to work or hitting up a party, this pencil gives me the perfect base for any lip color. And even when I’m eating or drinking, it doesn’t budge. Thank you, MAC Lip Pencil Chestnut, for being my trusty sidekick!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. MAC Lip Pencil Soar 5g

 MAC Lip Pencil Soar 5g

1. “I have to say, I was a little skeptical about trying out the MAC Lip Pencil Soar 5g at first. I mean, how different could it really be from other lip pencils? But let me tell you, this thing is a game changer! I tried it out on a whim and now I can’t imagine my makeup routine without it. It’s like the perfect wing-woman for my lipsticks and glosses, giving them that extra boost of long-lasting color and definition. Thanks MAC Lip Pencil Soar 5g, you’ve got yourself a loyal fan in me!

2. “If you’re anything like me, then you know the struggle of finding the perfect lip color that suits your skin tone. Well let me introduce you to my secret weapon – the MAC Lip Pencil Soar 5g! This universal shade is seriously magic – it somehow manages to complement every single one of my lip colors and skin tones. Plus, the creamy formula makes application a breeze and ensures that my look lasts all day long. Trust me, your lips will thank you for adding this gem to your makeup collection.”

3. “Okay guys, listen up – I’ve got some insider info for you all. The MAC Lip Pencil Soar 5g is hands down one of THE best lip products out there right now! Not only does it have a smooth texture that glides on seamlessly (seriously though, no clumps or tugging here), but it also gives me customizable coverage for whatever look I’m going for – subtle or bold. And let’s not forget its special talent of making any lipstick or gloss look like a million bucks when layered on top! MAC Lip Pencil Soar 5g, you have my heart (and lips).”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Mac Lip Pencil Mahogany is My Go-To Lip Liner

As someone who loves wearing lipstick on a daily basis, I have tried my fair share of lip liners. However, none have come close to the quality and versatility of Mac Lip Pencil in Mahogany. Here are a few reasons why this lip liner is an essential part of my makeup routine:

1. Perfect shade for everyday wear: The shade Mahogany is a beautiful warm-toned brown that complements my medium skin tone perfectly. It is not too dark or too light, making it suitable for everyday wear. I can easily pair it with various lipstick shades, from nudes to reds, without worrying about it clashing with my complexion.

2. Long-lasting formula: One of the biggest struggles I have faced with other lip liners is their staying power. Many tend to fade or smudge throughout the day, requiring constant touch-ups. However, Mac Lip Pencil in Mahogany stays put for hours on end without any need for reapplication. This makes it ideal for long days at work or events where I want my lipstick to stay in place.

3. Versatile application: This lip pencil has

My Buying Guide on ‘Mac Lip Pencil Mahogany’

As a makeup enthusiast, I have tried numerous lip pencils over the years and one that has stood out to me is the Mac Lip Pencil in Mahogany. This iconic shade has become a staple in my makeup collection and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a versatile and long-lasting lip pencil. In this buying guide, I will share my first-hand experience with the Mac Lip Pencil in Mahogany and provide all the necessary information to help you make an informed purchase.

The Shade

The shade Mahogany is a deep reddish-brown that complements a wide range of skin tones. It has warm undertones which make it perfect for everyday wear or to pair with bold lip colors. The color payoff is intense and rich, making it perfect for creating a defined lip shape or as an all-over lip color. I have also found that it can be worn alone or paired with various lipstick shades to add depth and longevity to your lip color.

The Formula

The Mac Lip Pencil in Mahogany has a creamy and smooth formula that glides on effortlessly without tugging on the lips. It is highly pigmented, so you only need one swipe for full coverage. The texture is not too dry or too creamy, making it easy to apply without smudging or feathering. The formula also contains moisturizing ingredients such as Jojoba oil, which helps keep your lips hydrated throughout the day.

The Longevity

One of the most impressive features of this lip pencil is its longevity. Once applied, it stays put for hours without fading or smudging. I have worn it through meals and drinks, and it still looks freshly applied at the end of the day. This makes it perfect for special occasions or long days when you don’t have time for touch-ups.

The Packaging

The Mac Lip Pencil comes in a sleek black packaging with a cap that matches the shade inside, making it easy to identify in your makeup bag. The pencil itself is retractable, so no sharpening is required, which means less product wastage. The tip is also precise enough for precise application without any need for a separate lip brush.

The Price

The price of the Mac Lip Pencil may seem steep compared to other drugstore brands, but trust me when I say that it’s worth every penny. The quality of this product justifies its price tag as it lasts much longer than other cheaper options.

Final Thoughts

Overall, I highly recommend the Mac Lip Pencil in Mahogany for anyone looking for a versatile and long-lasting lip pencil. Its creamy formula, intense pigmentation, and longevity make it worth every penny spent. Whether you are someone who prefers bold looks or natural everyday makeup, this shade will not disappoint you. So go ahead and add this cult-favorite shade to your collection; you won’t regret it!

Author Profile

Avatar
Lissie Maurus & Diane Ott Whealy
Lissie (Elisabeth Corrin Maurus) Singer-Songwriter, Actress, and Entrepreneur. Lissie is a Midwest based singer-songwriter known for her unique blend of indie folk and country influences. Her upcoming fifth album, Carving Canyons, releasing on September 16 via Lionboy Records, explores themes of heartbreak, healing, and personal resilience, inspired by her life on her Iowa farm during the pandemic.

Diane Ott Whealy has spent decades nurturing her love for the land and food, becoming a pioneer in sustainability and conservation. Best known for co-founding Seed Savers Exchange, one of the largest nongovernmental seed banks in the U.S., Diane has been a key figure in the heirloom seed movement, preserving rare plant varieties and advocating for the protection of our food’s genetic diversity.

Starting in 2024, Diane Ott Whealy and Lissie Maurus have expanded their passion for creativity and sustainability by launching an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first hand usage reviews. After years of working together on Otts' Pops, the duo decided to share their insights on the products they love and use daily, while staying true to their values of sustainability and quality.

Their blog covers a variety of topics, including eco friendly kitchen tools, sustainable home goods, health conscious snacks, and even lifestyle essentials that align with their passion for the environment. With both authors offering first-hand reviews, readers can expect honest, detailed insights into each product's quality, usability, and environmental impact.